| more


Catfish [2010]


Ostensibly a documentary about a young New York photographer (Nev Schulman), who develops an online relationship with a family in rural Michigan -- first with a talented 8-year-old girl who reproduces his photos as paintings and then with her 19-year-old half-sister. However, the circumstances may not be as they seem. Also with Megan Faccio and Melody C. Roscher. Directed by Henry Joost & Ariel Schulman. [1:34 - PG-13]



thumbs up

"There's no denying its strong narrative or its emotional pull... Decades from now, cultural anthropologists will likely find the film extremely useful in understanding what life was like in America in the early 21st century."

- Calvin Wilson

thumbs down

"You watch the film thinking what a true nonfiction artist like Frederick Wiseman or Heddy Honigmann might make of the material—certainly they wouldn’t indulge in such freak-show carnival barking."

- Keith Uhlich



Calvin Wilson | St. Louis Post-Dispatch
Peter Travers | Rolling Stone
Claudia Puig | USA Today
Noel Murray | Onion AV Club
Bill Goodykoontz | Arizona Republic
Roger Ebert | Chicago Sun-Times
Michael Phillips | Chicago Tribune
Rene Rodriguez | Miami Herald
Steven Rea | Philadelphia Inquirer
Shawn Levy | Portland Oregonian
Ann Hornaday | Washington Post
Dave McGinn | The Globe and Mail
David Edelstein | New York Magazine
Robert Abele | Los Angeles Times
Dana Stevens | Slate
Peter Debruge | Variety
John Defore | Hollywood Reporter
Cliff Doerksen | Chicago Reader
Kyle Smith | New York Post
Ty Burr | Boston Globe
James Berardinelli | ReelViews
Karina Longworth | Village Voice
A.O. Scott | The New York Times
Pam Grady | Boxoffice Magazine
Lisa Schwarzbaum | Entertainment Weekly
Peter Rainer | Christian Science Monitor
Marjorie Baumgarten | Austin Chronicle
G. Allen Johnson | San Francisco Examiner
Keith Uhlich | Time Out New York

Editor's Note: We use a 5-star scale, from 0 to 5 stars in ½ star increments, which is the standard in the U.S. For critics who use a 4-star scale, letters, percentages, or no ratings at all, we take the liberty of interpreting their reviews to fit our rating scale.

Copyright © 1992- Critics Inc. All rights reserved. "Critical Consensus™" & "Dueling Critics™" are Service Marks of Critics Inc. For legal queries please see our Terms of Use; for comments or questions see our contact info.